Dear Reader,
So far,
the book has been pretty confusing for me. It gets annoying at points because
there are no quotation marks around any of the dialogue. Sometime I need to
stop and go over what I had just read because I was not sure if it was dialogue
or not.
From
the start of the book I like how he doesn’t try to make his childhood sound
like a happy time. He comes straight out right away and says “It was, of
course, a miserable childhood: the happy childhood is hardly worth your while”
(11). He knows that fact and doesn’t try to change it or make himself think
differently. That is one of my favorite characteristics about Frank; he doesn’t
lie, or change the facts that others might. From the very first page I realized
that this book won’t be a very happy and exciting book. He life is horrible, “nothing
can compare with the Irish version: the poverty; the shiftless loquacious
alcoholic father; the pious defeated mother moaning by the fire; pompous
priests; bullying schoolmasters; the English and the terrible things they did
to us for eight hundred long years” (11). He says that other people complain, but no one
has it as bad as him.
This definitely
made me think differently about my life, and how I am living currently. I get
aggravated and/or annoyed with simple things. Like if we don’t have food in the
house, I am most likely going to complain. After reading chapters 1 and 2, I
thought differently. I shouldn’t be complaining if there are people out there,
like Frank, who has it so much worse than I do. He had to sit through his whole
life with his family and other factors falling apart and he doesn’t complain
nearly as much as I would if I had to go do a chore. This makes me feel a lot
more grateful and glad I have the things that I do.
He is
not the only character in this story that I feel bad for; I feel bad for his
whole family. No one is living happily in that family, and each one is a
different reason. I feel so bad for his mother because of the fact that Frank’s
sister died. After that his mother got very depressed. I also feel bad for his
father. I feel bad for him because “Malachy got drunk” (17) all the time. Most
other people probably wouldn’t feel bad because they would say that it was his
fault, or he can quit whenever. I do feel bad because once he does start, it is
an addiction, therefore is hard to stop. I also feel bad for the kids, because
they cannot help with any of this, all they can do Is live with it.
I am
hoping that as the book goes on, things will turn out okay, but I’ll just have
to wait until then.
Sincerely,
Adam
Dear Adam,
ReplyDeleteI felt the same way with the dialogue! It was confusing but got a little easier. I still sometimes have to go back and reread the paragraph. It was interesting to know how this story would go. It made me more intrigued to know that it wasn't going to be happy. That was my favorite characteristic about him as well. Reading your third paragraph did make me think about my life. I never actually thought about it that way before. This link talks about what the Irish immigrants went through http://library.thinkquest.org/20619/Irish.html. It makes everything even more surreal. He had it hard and I mean really hard. I'm glad you brought that up because I did not even think about it. You made a great point about how Malachy is addicted to drinking and it would be hard for him too stop. That got me thinking as well. I like how you thought about the events in this book.
Sincerely,
Perry Joubert